Ads

How to set up Meta Ads audiences: broad, custom and lookalike

A plain-language guide to broad targeting, custom audiences, lookalike audiences and remarketing in Facebook and Instagram ads, and when to use each.

By Sercan Horkal · · 6 min read

The biggest change in Meta advertising over the years is this: the algorithm can predict who will convert better than you can, but only with the right data and the right creative. That is why audience setup has moved away from the “the narrower the better” mindset.

Three basic audience types

1. Broad audience (few interest restrictions)

You settle for basic criteria such as age, location and language, and leave room for the algorithm. It often works well in accounts with enough conversion data. With little data and a small budget, you may see scattered results in the first days.

2. Custom audience

Made up of people who have already interacted with you:

  • Website visitors (via the Meta pixel or Conversions API)
  • Customer lists (email or phone, uploaded with consent and lawfully)
  • People who engaged with your Instagram or Facebook page
  • Video viewers and lead form openers

3. Lookalike audience

Finds new people who resemble the source audience you provide. The better the source, the better the result. Using “purchasers” or “high-value customers” as the source usually gives a stronger signal than “all visitors”.

Structure by funnel stage

  • Cold audience (awareness): Broad or lookalike. The goal is to introduce the brand and bring relevant visitors.
  • Warm audience (consideration): Video viewers, social engagement, site visitors. The goal is to build trust and answer questions.
  • Hot audience (decision): Cart abandoners, product page viewers, people who started a form. The goal is to complete the action.

Write a different message for each stage. “Last 24 hours” pressure suits a cold audience poorly, and brand storytelling suits a hot one poorly.

Exclusion audiences

Exclude existing customers, recent purchasers and employees from campaigns that target new customers. This simple step stops budget being spent repeatedly on the same people.

Audience overlap and fragmentation

If you open separate ad sets with very similar audiences, you compete against yourself and each set lacks the data it needs to learn. A small number of clearly separated audiences often works better.

Creative is part of targeting too

In broad audiences, the creative and copy largely decide who converts. Test a few creatives based on different problems and benefits, and build data on which message attracts which audience.

No audience without measurement

  • The Meta pixel and, where possible, server-side sending (Conversions API) should be set up.
  • Important events (purchase, lead, add to cart) should be defined correctly.
  • Your cookie and consent setup should meet legal requirements.

Common mistakes

  • Over-narrow targeting. The audience gets too small and costs rise.
  • Building a lookalike from a tiny source. With too little data, results are weak.
  • Mixing everything in one campaign. Separate cold and hot audiences.
  • Blaming the audience and forgetting the creative.

For campaign setup and management, see our Meta Ads service.

Want help with this?

Let’s talk

Get a quote

Tell us about your project.

Write your goal in a few lines and we will reply within 1 business day.